Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life? My Private Answer.

pro choice pro life

I was fully supportive (but very sad) when a girlfriend many years ago aborted a baby we would’ve had.

I am fervently pro-choice. I will never be otherwise.

She didn’t tell me she was doing it.

She told me she was pregnant. Told me she needed to be alone. She was crying and then hung up.

I tried calling, visiting, stalking, everything for three days. No answer or response.

“I want you to have the baby,” is last thing I said to her.

And then she contacted me and told me she had an abortion. She told me a month later she would’ve named a girl “Daisy” after my grandma. She was crying when she said it.

Inside I was devastated. But my job was to comfort her and I did. And six months later we broke up.

I am just as much pro-choice. If it’s possible to be more than I was then, then I am more.

A friend of mine is pro-life. We have been close friends for 18 years. I seldom talk on the phone with anyone but my friend and I talk on the phone with him 2-3 times a day.

Most people are “single issue” people. I will define that as: “if you don’t believe in my issue, you are not my friend.”

There’s a lot of reasons to not be friends with someone.

One time I had a friend who consistently would put me down. Or find reasons to be upset at me whenever something good was happening in my life.

The key to success in any relationship: personal, familial, business, etc is NOT that the two people are supportive during bad times but that the two people are supportive during GOOD times.

This is what happens. “Honey, I got a great opportunity but I have to spend two weeks of every month shooting a movie in LA but I’ll be back as much as possible.”

Response: “Oh! And I have to be alone and doing nothing while you’re off achieving big success.”

This relationship will fail. It’s already failed.

Have you been in a relationship like that?

I exaggerate in the above example but this happens in many relationships, including ones I’ve been in. And it happens with family members, lovers, business partners, friends, etc.

Do you have a friend who feeds off your bad times?

This is a “one strike and your out” policy for me.

The above statement is a lie now that I think about it.

To be honest, for me it’s usually 50 strikes, 75 arguments, and maybe even someone spitting in m face. I’m trying to get better though.

I’m that pathetic in my relationships. Particularly romantic ones where the 14 year acned, braces, awkward kid inside of me can’t actually believe that a “girl” likes him.

Yes…spitting on me. And I would’ve returned the spit except my spit is more like a spray. Like an old man peeing and hitting everything but the toilet. I need to practice my spit.

Some people can shoot that saliva like a gun and hit a target 20 feet away. As I write this, I doubt I can hit the monitor on this computer with my best attempt at a spit.

Anyway. the lesson is: don’t spit.

Back to my friend who is pro-life.

Why is he pro-life? Because he’s religious. Because his parents are religious. Because he goes to church 2-3x a week.

Because he believes that anything that has the beginnings of a brain should have the chance to live. Because because because.

Do I agree with him? Absolutely not.

No law should EVER legislate what a person does with their body.

Life is hard enough without clueless bureaucrats dictating what a woman can do with her body.

If we give the law our choices, then we give the law our lives.

I know a lot of people who would not be friends with someone who is pro-life. And I know pro-life people who would not be fiends with someone who is pro-choice.

I am anti-college for instance. (“anti” and “pro” seem juvenile but there it is).

I have lost what I thought were very good friends because I am anti-college.

I am anti-war. I have an 18 year old daughter. I would sooner volunteer myself to a war than ever allow her to shoot another human being because someone commanded her to do it.

And yes, that includes World War II, the Civil War, and the Revolutionary War, and any war. I would just as soon be a slave myself than require a war.

Maybe I’m stupid. Maybe some wars are justified. But I don’t believe it.

And, I’ve lost friends over this. For instance, people think that the Civil War was the only way to stop slavery. It wasn’t. History is misunderstood here.

There’s no way to easily explain it. But, for instance, if the Revolutionary War never happened, most likely slavery would’ve been banned in 1833 when the British Empire banned it.

(Note: I’m not arguing this. I could be 100% wrong. Slavery is the most despicable crime ever. But the Civil War was also the worst war in American history as measured by per capital lives lost).

And it’s not as if minority lives suddenly became, “GREAT!” because of the civil war.

It’s been a 150 year process and just yesterday police killed an innocent black student at close gun point.

This is a huge and terrifying and sad problem that exists RIGHT NOW and is killing mentally ill people and minorities every day.

Dwight Eisenhower, one of the most successful generals in history, warned when he was President about a phrase he coined “the military-indiustrial complex”.

The intimate relationship between business and war. Well, business is booming!

Back to my pro-life friend. Best friend. How can you be best friends with someone who is pro-life, many of my pro-choice friends ask.

Pro-life people want to invade a woman’s body. Force her into back alley abortions where she can die.

I get that. I agree with it. I do think the word would be far worse if pro-choice laws were repealed. I am scared of this. I have two daughters. The law should not touch their bodies.


Actions > Thoughts

Pro-choice people, of which I am one, have it difficult.

They have flimsy laws that barely protect the rights they believe in. And those rights are ALWAYS under attack every day, in every state, in every court.

So pro-choice groups often have to take extremes.

For instance, many pro-choice groups refuse the existence of post-abortion traumatic stress.

The idea that women who have abortion can suffer life-damaging emotional consequences for many months or years.

Some pro-choice groups say there is no scientific evidence of this.

I’ve seen many women go through this. It’s horribly devastating to their lives.

They get depressed and medication can’t help. Talk can’t help. And it ruins their lives, careers, and relationships, and can lead to suicide.

Pro-choice groups tend to avoid anything that suggests there is a negative consequence to abortion for the strategic reason of: why give the pro-life movement any ammo.

It’s hard enough protecting the pro-choice laws we have!

I get it. It’s strategic. But I know post-abortion stress exists and is a killer.

And yet, I’m pro-choice.


Here’s what my friend who is Pro-Life does:

He opens his house to foster children. “Kids who come from broken or abusive families deserve to have a loving home. ”

Pro-choice or Pro-life advocates often leave behind their beliefs at birth. The battle is over at that point for them.

But many pro-life people have to ask: what if a child is born into an unfortunate circumstance.

My friend DOES something about it. He helps those children. He donates to charities helping those children.

My friend’s wife, a lawyer, offers legal counsel for free to help those children find good adoptive homes. Many children have found loving homes as a result,. including in my friend’s home.

How many people would open up their home (and their birth children) to a baby born with AIDS?

My friend’s and his wife help counsel the mothers of children they give up for adoption to help them deal with their choices and their sadness.

My friend’s wife counsels women who HAVE abortions and are now undergoing depression. She doesn’t judge. She doesn’t tell them she’s pro-life. She helps.

ACTIONS change the world. Not beliefs.

When I was severely depressed because of the situation with that long ago ex-girlfriend and her decision that I supported, he was there for me.

He spoke to me every day. He often secretly did my work when I disappeared for weeks at a time, lying in my room depressed and unable to move.

Do we argue? Do I try to convince him or he me? Never. Sometimes he gives me his reasons and sometimes I give him mine.

Because we respect each other, the result is that we each learn. But changing an opinion doesn’t mean anything.


Actions follow intentions.

If your intention is to always be the kindest person in any given moment then your actions can change the world.

Actions are more important than a vote. Than a Facebook post. Than anger. Than a Twitter “block”. Actions > Hate.

Hate only leads to more hate. Loving deeds lead to love. No issues involved.

The pro-life and pro-choice people argue and hate each other every day.

But the ACTION people save lives and the ARGUE people block people on Facebook. Don’t be pro-argue.

My friend is pro-Action. And so am I.

[Image is of twins “kissing” in a sonogram]

The Journey towards Personal Freedom Starts with YOU

It's time to make the most important decision of your life: Choose Yourself.

I will show you how...

Every weekday I'll send my latest stories, ideas and exclusive interviews straight to your inbox.

Sign up below for Altucher Confidential, my FREE e-letter.

By submitting your email address, you will receive a free subscription to Altucher Confidential. This daily investment newsletter delivers free independent financial forecasting and commentary along with carefully selected products and services that we think might interest you. We will not share your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Statement.

  • Linda Sand

    Yes. My primary argument with those who are pro-life has to do with what they are doing about those unwanted babies. I could be friends with your friend.

    • pacman

      so you kill them. great logic.

  • Ron Baylin

    Sorry James but you’re wrong. A life is a life. You do the deed, you handle the consequences. I’m about as far from a religious person as you can get, it’s about the sanctity of life. I can see exceptions in certain cases, but far too often abortion is just post-coital birth control. I whole heartedly disagree with you.

  • lisajh

    Always a difficult topic. I am pro-choice because life is not black and white. But, I do think it’s abhorrent if it’s used as birth control. It should only be for real oops or life threatening things. Education is also an issue. Too many parents do everything they can to never talk about sex with thier kids. I never had sex until I could handle the consequence.

  • pacman

    “Why is he pro-life? Because he’s religious. Because his parents are religious. Because he goes to church 2-3x a week.” I’m not religious at all and yet I am pro-life. You’re dead wrong if you think the question is about what a woman does with her body. The question is, does a woman have the right to dispose of the life a baby resulting from an act she willingly participated in. I seriously doubt any female of childbearing age isn’t aware that sex can result in pregnancy. Stipulation, the question becomes far less clear in the case of rape.

  • Jeannine Jackson

    I don’t think the point of this article is pro-life or pro-choice. If you didn’t read to the end and are hung up on the abortion issue, you missed the point. James is saying back up your position on any issue with positive action, not more negative words.

  • MiykaEl_TX

    It’s not her body and she doesn’t have the right to Murder it.

  • Belen Trevino

    I agree with Jeannine she right you missed the point!